•  
  •  
 

Keywords

Analytic Philosophy, Inclusion, Performative Utterances, Philosophy of Language, Speech Act Theory

Abstract

In Indifference to Difference or in Deference to Difference: A Treatise of Inclusion, Dr. Noel S. Pariñas “argues that the alternatives or disjuncts in the strict or exclusive disjunction are mutually exclusive: either we include or exclude - no middle ground.[1]” The argument then goes further to say that non-absolute inclusion in one way necessitates exclusion in another. This is perhaps best summarized by how he examines RA No. 9262 and concludes that because it specifically highlights women and children, it does not provide an equivalent protection for men in society in cases of domestic violence. I argue that this analysis based on syllogistic logic, is flawed for two interrelated reasons: the first is the irreducibility of certain statements to logic, the second is the usage of the myopic and limiting lens of exclusionary positivism in viewing social phenomena. While Pariñas’ article is a prime example of these flaws, it is not an isolated case in the philosophical community. It is therefore hoped that the following account provides a sobering view for philosophers everywhere who choose to critically examine society and its problems. As a positive contribution to this end, I propose that the analysis of RA No. 9262 should instead go through the lens of performative utterances and speech acts, as the creation and implementation of this law goes beyond the mere logical valuation of its propositions but towards what message sends to the Filipino people regarding social justice and the struggle for inclusion and equality.

Share

COinS